In this episode of Pick The Pro, Everton defenders James Tarkowski and James Garner face off against five athletes in a series of football challenges designed to test skill and instinct. The task is simple yet tricky: identify which one among them is a current or former professional footballer. Rounds include shooting accuracy, two-on-two play, first touch precision, and a final individual challenge. Each round highlights technique, movement, and decision-making under pressure, offering viewers a close look at the subtle differences between amateur talent and seasoned pro-level performance.
The format blends entertainment with insight, showcasing how experience shapes execution on the pitch. As the rounds progress, the duo must rely on their knowledge of the game and keen observation to make the correct guess. With no clear visual indicators, the identity of the professional remains hidden until the final reveal. The episode provides a fun and engaging way to appreciate the nuances of elite footballing ability while highlighting the dedication required to reach that level.