The review of the film adaptation of Colleen Hoover’s work highlights significant flaws in the storyline, particularly pointing out a lack of logical consistency. The plot centers on Scotty Landry, who dies in a car accident, and Kenna, a character who reacts dramatically by stealing Scotty’s motorcycle despite his dislike of memorials. The movie is described as a tearjerker but is criticized for its implausible narrative choices and emotional manipulation.
This latest adaptation follows a pattern of previous films based on Hoover’s novels, which have also faced criticism for similar reasons. The review suggests that the film struggles to maintain credibility, resulting in a disappointing viewing experience. Despite these issues, the emotional themes are clear, but the execution leaves much to be desired, making it a less satisfying adaptation for fans and newcomers alike.